Italy’s Last-Minute Triumph Over Israel in World Cup Qualifier

Tonali’s Late Heroics Seal Unforgettable Win for Italy

Italy’s 2026 World Cup qualifying campaign took a dramatic turn on September 8, 2025, as Sandro Tonali’s stoppage-time goal clinched a 5-4 victory over Israel in Debrecen, Hungary. The match, filled with twists and emotional swings, showcased both the promise and vulnerability of the Italian national team under new coach Gennaro Gattuso.

A Match Marked by Momentum Swings

The encounter between Italy and Israel was anything but predictable. Italy entered the match needing a win to keep their qualifying hopes alive, and the stakes were evident from the opening whistle. Israel, however, struck first, putting pressure on the four-time world champions and exposing defensive gaps that have troubled Italy in recent years.

Moise Kean emerged as a key figure for Italy, scoring twice to overturn Israel’s early advantage. His goals, combined with contributions from teammates, propelled Italy to a 4-2 lead by the 81st minute. The Azzurri appeared to be cruising toward a much-needed victory, but the closing moments of the match would prove anything but routine.

Late Collapse Raises Familiar Questions

Just as Italy seemed to have secured the three points, their defensive frailties resurfaced. In the 88th minute, Dor Peretz scored his second goal for Israel, narrowing the gap and injecting tension into the final minutes. The drama intensified when Alessandro Bastoni, under pressure, inadvertently turned the ball into his own net in the 90th minute, leveling the score at 4-4. For Italian fans, the specter of another disappointing result loomed large, especially with memories of recent failed World Cup qualification campaigns still fresh.

Tonali’s Decisive Moment

With the match seemingly destined for a draw, Sandro Tonali stepped up in the 91st minute. The midfielder, known for his composure and vision, unleashed a speculative shot through a crowded penalty area. The ball found its way past the Israeli defense and goalkeeper, sparking jubilant celebrations among Italian players and supporters. Tonali’s goal not only secured a vital win but also demonstrated the resilience and determination that Italy will need as the qualifying campaign continues.

Gattuso’s Impact and Honest Assessment

This fixture marked one of the first major tests for Gennaro Gattuso as Italy’s head coach. The former midfield enforcer has brought renewed energy to the squad, but the chaotic nature of this victory highlighted the challenges he faces. Gattuso did not shy away from criticism after the match, candidly admitting that his team conceded “absurd goals” and showed signs of fragility. “We need to work on our focus and composure,” Gattuso remarked, emphasizing the importance of learning from such high-pressure situations.

Despite the defensive lapses, Gattuso praised his players’ fighting spirit and the crucial three points earned. The win moves Italy above Israel in Group I, placing them in a play-off position and just three points behind group leaders Norway. With several matches remaining, Italy’s path to direct qualification remains open, but improvements are necessary to avoid another World Cup absence.

Implications for Group I Standings

Italy’s victory has significant implications for the Group I standings. By overtaking Israel, the Azzurri have strengthened their bid for at least a play-off spot, while keeping pressure on Norway at the top of the group. Every match in the remaining fixtures will be decisive, as Italy seeks to avoid the disappointment of missing a third consecutive World Cup finals. The stakes could not be higher for a nation with such a rich footballing tradition.

Key Performers and Tactical Insights

Moise Kean’s brace was instrumental in turning the tide for Italy, showcasing his ability to deliver in high-stakes situations. Sandro Tonali’s leadership in midfield and his match-winning goal further underlined his growing importance to the national team. However, the defensive errors, particularly in the closing stages, highlighted areas that Gattuso and his staff must address urgently.

Tactically, Italy displayed attacking intent and creativity, but lapses in concentration and organization at the back nearly cost them dearly. The balance between offense and defense will be a central focus as the team prepares for its next qualifying fixtures.

Looking Ahead: Italy’s Road to the World Cup

With this dramatic win, Italy has injected new life into their World Cup qualifying campaign. The team’s ability to respond under pressure will be tested again in the coming months, as every point becomes crucial. Gattuso’s leadership, combined with the talent of players like Kean and Tonali, offers hope that Italy can overcome their recent struggles and secure a place at the 2026 World Cup in North America.

For now, Italian fans can celebrate a memorable night in Debrecen—a night that may prove to be a turning point in their journey back to football’s biggest stage.